⁉️ Friends, unfortunately an experience that was truly disappointing...
⁉️ Friends, unfortunately an experience that was truly disappointing...
In the Iranian year 1398, I ran into exactly this same problem on TradingView. Back then I tried several times, but each time it hit a dead end, and in the end I gave up on publishing my projects publicly.
Over these few years I tried again many times, but the result did not change. For example, see our previous posts.
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/502
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/552
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/567
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/568
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/583
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/1265
This year, with the progress of artificial intelligence, I told myself that maybe this time things would be different. To make sure there was no fault on my side, I got help from several different AIs to review the code, the strategy logic, money management, backtest results and even the description text line by line.
My goal was just one thing: to be able to offer traders a new service publicly and for free.
That is why I have been spending time for several weeks on publishing a number of my strategies on TradingView. ⏳
✅ I fixed every issue they reported.
✅ I rewrote the entire code structure.
✅ I changed the strategy logic.
✅ I wrote the descriptions several times more thoroughly.
✅ I corrected the money management, backtest, commission and slippage.
✅ I even got help from several different AIs to check the code and the publishing rules line by line, so that if even the slightest issue existed, it would be found and fixed.
But what was the result? 😡
🔴 Once again, the same generic and repetitive messages:
• Originality and usefulness
• Description
• Strategy Results
❌ Without saying precisely, even once, which part of the code, which section of the description or which strategy logic has a problem.
When a developer is not told exactly where the problem is, fixing it is no longer a technical process; it turns into guessing the moderator's personal taste!
Worst of all, every day I see scripts that:
⚪️ Have very short descriptions.
⚪️ Are a combination of several indicators.
⚪️ Provide no particular technical explanation.
Yet they get published without any problem.
By contrast, for some developers, a new generic objection is raised every time, without any specific solution being offered.
📌 If a rule exists, it must be applied equally to everyone.
📌 If a script is rejected, it must be stated exactly:
🔹 Which line?
🔹 Which section?
🔹 Which clause of the rules?
Not a few generic sentences sent each time, with the developer rewriting everything from scratch again.
I have no problem with technical criticism. In fact, I welcome it. 💯
But I do have a problem with vague, non-transparent decisions that come without a precise explanation.
Transparency, fairness and measurable criteria are the minimum that any developer expects from a professional platform. ⚖️
I hope that one day the script review process will be based on clear, citable criteria, not on generic and subjective impressions.
#review #injustice #TradingView #TradingView
https://twitter.com/omid_mokri🅲🅾️🅸🅽 🅺🆄🆁🅳 👾Discord 🎥Youtube 📸Instagram 💬X
In the Iranian year 1398, I ran into exactly this same problem on TradingView. Back then I tried several times, but each time it hit a dead end, and in the end I gave up on publishing my projects publicly.
Over these few years I tried again many times, but the result did not change. For example, see our previous posts.
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/502
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/552
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/567
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/568
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/583
https://t.me/Coin_Kurd/1265
This year, with the progress of artificial intelligence, I told myself that maybe this time things would be different. To make sure there was no fault on my side, I got help from several different AIs to review the code, the strategy logic, money management, backtest results and even the description text line by line.
My goal was just one thing: to be able to offer traders a new service publicly and for free.
That is why I have been spending time for several weeks on publishing a number of my strategies on TradingView. ⏳
✅ I fixed every issue they reported.
✅ I rewrote the entire code structure.
✅ I changed the strategy logic.
✅ I wrote the descriptions several times more thoroughly.
✅ I corrected the money management, backtest, commission and slippage.
✅ I even got help from several different AIs to check the code and the publishing rules line by line, so that if even the slightest issue existed, it would be found and fixed.
But what was the result? 😡
🔴 Once again, the same generic and repetitive messages:
• Originality and usefulness
• Description
• Strategy Results
❌ Without saying precisely, even once, which part of the code, which section of the description or which strategy logic has a problem.
When a developer is not told exactly where the problem is, fixing it is no longer a technical process; it turns into guessing the moderator's personal taste!
Worst of all, every day I see scripts that:
⚪️ Have very short descriptions.
⚪️ Are a combination of several indicators.
⚪️ Provide no particular technical explanation.
Yet they get published without any problem.
By contrast, for some developers, a new generic objection is raised every time, without any specific solution being offered.
📌 If a rule exists, it must be applied equally to everyone.
📌 If a script is rejected, it must be stated exactly:
🔹 Which line?
🔹 Which section?
🔹 Which clause of the rules?
Not a few generic sentences sent each time, with the developer rewriting everything from scratch again.
I have no problem with technical criticism. In fact, I welcome it. 💯
But I do have a problem with vague, non-transparent decisions that come without a precise explanation.
Transparency, fairness and measurable criteria are the minimum that any developer expects from a professional platform. ⚖️
I hope that one day the script review process will be based on clear, citable criteria, not on generic and subjective impressions.
#review #injustice #TradingView #TradingView
https://twitter.com/omid_mokri🅲🅾️🅸🅽 🅺🆄🆁🅳 👾Discord 🎥Youtube 📸Instagram 💬X
Persian original · View this post on Telegram ↗ · Open in the archive · 💬 Discuss in the Coin_Kurd Telegram group · Educational, not financial advice.